Don’t miss Affiliate Summit West this January 12 - 14 in Las Vegas! Connect directly with top industry voices tackling the AI revolution head-on, Get actionable insights from SEO leaders, affiliate pros, and digital disruptors and future-proof your marketing game in an era of AI-powered search.
As e-commerce founders and brand advertisers, a new question now sits at the heart of your growth strategy: How can you ensure your products earn a spot in ChatGPT’s recommendations and, ultimately, get purchased directly within an AI-powered conversation?
With the advent of ChatGPT Checkout, OpenAI’s latest foray into agentic commerce the rules of product visibility and conversion are changing. The practical implications are urgent: if product rankings in ChatGPT become a new gatekeeper for online sales, understanding the factors that shape them is now essential to your bottom line.
This blog takes a measured, analytical tour through what ChatGPT Checkout is, how it works, and, crucially, how your products might be ranked. Beyond the surface, we’ll weigh the likely and emerging signals involved, drawing on early data and expert commentary. The goal is to provide you with the clarity, and actionable insight, you need to adapt your strategies for the next phase of AI-driven commerce.
What is ChatGPT Checkout? A Factual Primer
ChatGPT Checkout is OpenAI’s newly-launched feature that allows users to purchase products directly within the ChatGPT chat interface. This isn’t a theoretical vision it’s already operational for U.S. users across Free, Plus, and Pro plans, supporting purchases from Etsy sellers and, soon, over a million Shopify merchants. The promise is deceptively simple: when a user asks ChatGPT for a product recommendation say, “best wireless earbuds under $100” the AI surfaces a curated set of product cards. If a product supports Instant Checkout, users can buy it, confirm shipping and payment details, and complete the transaction without leaving the chat.
The engine powering this seamless experience is the Agentic Commerce Protocol (ACP), an open, secure standard co-developed with Stripe. ACP orchestrates the entire checkout process: the user’s payment is processed via Stripe or the merchant’s existing provider; the merchant remains the merchant of record, handling fulfillment, returns, and support. Importantly, only the bare minimum of user data is shared, and only with the user’s consent. This respects privacy and gives both shoppers and brands confidence in the system’s integrity.
This is not a closed loop. By open-sourcing the ACP, OpenAI invites broader adoption: merchants can integrate with minimal development, and developers can innovate on top of the protocol. As of today, single-item purchases are supported. Multi-item carts, expanded merchant participation, and rollout to new regions are all on the roadmap.
For brands, the implications are twofold. First, Instant Checkout is not just a new sales channel it’s a new kind of distribution, embedded at the point of product discovery, inside a platform used by hundreds of millions each week. Second, it’s a channel where you don’t lose autonomy: payments, customer relationships, and data flows remain under your control. The only fees are a transaction charge to OpenAI, with no added cost to the shopper.
Decoding Product Rankings in ChatGPT Checkout
With ChatGPT now acting as both recommender and purchasing agent, the mechanics of product ranking take on newfound urgency for brands. OpenAI is clear that, for now, rankings are organic and unsponsored no pay-to-play, no hidden ads. So what does determine which products make the shortlist in response to a shopping query?
The publicly stated answers are “relevance to the query,” “availability,” “price,” “quality,” whether the merchant is the primary seller, and whether Instant Checkout is enabled. At first glance, these sound like the classic levers of e-commerce platforms everywhere. But the reality, as early data and practitioner experience show, is more nuanced and still evolving.
First, the ChatGPT environment sharply limits the number of products surfaced in any interaction. Unlike Google’s endless blue links or Amazon’s scrollable catalog, ChatGPT typically returns only a handful of recommendations. This scarcity makes inclusion not just desirable but existential for brands if you’re not on the shortlist, you are invisible.
Among the signals that seem to matter most are the completeness and accuracy of your product data. Brands with clean, fully populated feeds including details like GTIN, variant information, up-to-date stock and pricing, and robust schema markup get surfaced far more often. Structured data is critical, not just for discoverability but for the AI’s ability to answer follow-up questions (“show me only the black version” or “which one is quietest?”) with contextual accuracy.
External validation also appears influential. Star ratings, volume and freshness of customer reviews, and third-party mentions all serve as trust signals. Unlike traditional search, where on-site optimization can sometimes suffice, ChatGPT draws from reviews, publisher content, and even forums to build its product summaries and recommendations. Benefit-led copy explaining who the product is for, why it’s useful tends to be echoed and amplified by the AI, influencing both ranking and conversion.
Yet, there is still much we don’t know. While OpenAI currently excludes paid placements and says that enabling Instant Checkout does not guarantee preferential ranking, the underlying algorithm is not public. Practitioners have observed volatility in rankings; the same query can produce different recommendations at different times, likely reflecting ongoing model training and data ingestion. Signals like feed completeness, structured data, and review sentiment seem especially powerful but the weighting of these factors remains opaque.
Other speculative but plausible factors include behavioral signals (user engagement with product cards, dwell time, click-throughs), merchant profile strength, and integration depth (such as Shopify’s streamlined feeds versus smaller platforms). Some have noted that products performing well in Bing Shopping also surface more frequently in ChatGPT, hinting at shared data pipelines.
And looming over all these factors is the future possibility of monetization whether through sponsored placements, bid-based eligibility, or other forms of promotion. For now, however, the system is resolutely organic, making this a rare and crucial window for brands to earn their place through genuine product quality and data excellence.
Expert Perspectives: Frank Ravanelli on AI-Powered Checkout and the Future of E-Commerce
No discussion of AI-driven commerce would be complete without expert insight. Frank Ravanelli, VP of AI & Affiliates at FOREO, offers a resonant perspective on the systemic change underway. He points out that AI tools are already central to product discovery, selection, and purchase for the majority of online shoppers especially among Gen Z, Millennials, and Gen X. AI isn’t simply another channel; it’s fast becoming the main interface between consumers and brands.
Ravanelli warns that the rise of AI-powered environments like ChatGPT Checkout marks a “systemic and seismic change.” If your e-commerce funnel still relies on organic search traffic, the landscape is shifting beneath your feet. “If you are a publisher,” he writes, “you need to ‘own’ your audience” through newsletters, social channels, and direct relationships not just hope for ranking on Google.
The data supports this: ChatGPT-driven sessions though small in volume for now convert at rates multiple times higher than traditional organic search. The implication is clear. You must master AI in the way your customers actually use it not as you wish they did. This means adapting your product data, reviews, and content for AI-driven platforms, not just legacy search engines. It also means experimenting, tracking, and learning because the systems and their rules are evolving, often rapidly and unpredictably.
For brands, Ravanelli offers both a warning and an opportunity. Those that adapt to the new AI-driven “shortlist” model by investing in complete data, external validation, and direct audience engagement will find themselves ahead as others scramble to catch up. The AI platforms, by their nature, make room for high-quality, well-documented, and widely-mentioned products, regardless of company size.
But there is a strategic imperative, too. As Ravanelli notes, the ability to achieve economies of scale with AI means that even the “long tail” of less-prominent products can become commercially viable again for those able to adapt. Companies that ignore this could find themselves losing both their core and their fringe customers to AI-native competitors or bold incumbents investing strategically in these new distribution channels.
Closing Thoughts: What ChatGPT Checkout Means for Your Brand
ChatGPT Checkout is not merely a new feature it’s a harbinger of how digital commerce is being rebuilt, with AI at the center. The factors that influence product rankings data quality, external validation, benefit-driven content are not new, but the stakes and the dynamics have changed. Small brands have unprecedented opportunities to compete, but only if they adapt quickly and systematically.
The core advice is practical: treat ChatGPT Checkout as a new channel with its own rules, not as an extension of your existing SEO or paid search playbook. Invest in your product feeds, cultivate external reviews, and monitor performance vigilantly. This is a window of organic opportunity that may not last.
Above all, keep pace with your audience. They’re already using AI to discover, compare, and buy. The brands that thrive will be those who meet customers where they are, with complete information, trusted validation, and the agility to pivot as the AI ecosystem continues to evolve.
The future of e-commerce will not be won by those who wait for certainty, but by those who engage thoughtfully, experiment relentlessly, and adapt faster than their competitors. Now is the moment to act.
